Tuesday 3 May 2022

Memories we Lost 2021 KCSE Analysis

MEMORIES WE LOST: LIGHT ANALYSIS


KCSE PAST PAPERS REVISION: Review of KCSE 2021: Light-Lesley Nneka Arimah

 



Distance between parents and their children can be an obstacle to effective parenting. With reference to Lesley Nneka Arimah's story, “Light”, write an essay in support of this statement.

 


How to answer KCSE essay questions based on Memories we Lost

  1. Read the question keenly
  2. Identify KEYWORDS to help you interpret the question correctly
  3. Come up with points of interpretation

The keywords in the questions include “distance” and “obstacle in parenting”.

The candidate is required to identify the challenges the child goes through because of the distance between her and the mother.

In this case, distant parenting is different from single parenting.

The candidate was to point out the challenges the MOTHER has in raising her DAUGHTER brought about by her physical absence.

 

The points you give must be related to the events in the short story “Light”.

 

You can only score a full mark in each point if you cite adequate specific textual illustrations.

 

TASK

  1. Identify challenges experienced by Enebeli's daughter
  2. Tie each challenge to her mother’s physical absence

 

Reason why students lost marks in this question

  • Many students read and interpreted the question correctly.
  • However, most of them could not give sufficient textual illustrations despite it being a rather short story with few details.

The examiner did not demand too many details but as usual, the textual illustrations in short stories have to be specific and based on the episodes.

Students are encouraged to read the short story carefully and master the relevant details in each EPISODE.

For example, the note Enebeli's daughter sends to sends reads “Buki, I love you, I will give you many sons (P28) or how They SURVIVE the CRIME SCENE of the girl's first ‘MOON TIME”(P28).

Notably, more and more students are getting it right.

 

Memories we Lost essay: Light – introduction

  1. What is your interpretation of the question? What challenges do the children experience when one parent is away? With reference to “Light”, what are the challenges of distant parenting?
  2. Include the keywords in your introduction. Show how “distance” and the “obstacles” that come with it hinder effectual parenting.
  3. Paraphrase: do not simply rewrite the question and pass it off as an introduction.
  4. Contextualize: mention some of the obstacles.
  5. Be brief. (It carries only 2 marks)

 

Developing the body: Memories we Lost essays

  1. Give at least four well developed points
  2. Each point falls on separate paragraphs
  3. Give adequate textual illustrations on the obstacles to effective patenting caused but the distance between parents and children. Tie this to the episodes.

 

NB: Answer the question on the first line of each (body) paragraph, before you try to illustrate.

 

Points of interpretation

 

  • Boyfriend
  • Communication
  • Resentment
  • House girl
  • Lessons
  • Grooming
  • Taking sides

 

Paragraph development

Obstacle: The girl is fourteen now and is in trouble for engaging in a boy-girl relationship.

The mother tries to correct the girl, but the long absence dilutes much of her influence

Illustration (P28,29,30,32)

  • Three long years have passed since the mother went away
  • The girl is 14 and there is a boy
  • Enebeli has been invited to discuss the misdemeanor and now he is seated in the lobby to the head teacher’s office
  • The girl is in trouble for sending a boy notes, it's not the first time
  • The boy not appealing. He is short, one ear is larger than the other and he has a terrible hair cut. He is confused about the girl’s attention (P28)
  • The note reads, "Buki, I love you, I will give you many sons."
  • He promises to chastise the girl, assures the head teacher it will not happen again
  • It happens two more times, the girl later learns to pass notes better
  • Enebeli deems his daughter his brightest ember, he will not dim her
  • Mother attempts to correct her
  • Much is lost in transmission over the wire
  • Her influence is diluted by the DISTANCE
  • Enebeli and his wife disagree on training up of the girl (P29)
  • The girl opens up to the mother about the boy, strings out his virtues (P30)
  • He is finally learning to kiss well
  • Her mother silences her, did not think she would not raise such a girl
  • This dampens her
  • “And there is a little less light to her”.

 

The girl is involved in a boy-girl relationship (challenge) but the mother is too far (DISTANCE) hence she cannot correct her effectively and her influence has waned (OBSTACLE)

 

Sample set book essay question based on Memories we Lost (Light – Lesley Nneka Arimah)  

Distance between parents and their children can be an obstacle to effective parenting. With reference to Lesley Nneka Arimah’s story, “Light”, write an essay in support of this statement.

Parents may find themselves separated from their children because of work or study. The distance normally hinders effective parenting because it reduces communication between parent and child. “Light” by Lesley Nneka Arimah brings to light the effects of this separation.

The first challenge the girl experiences is a boy-girl relationship. Three years after her mother went to America to study for a Masters in Business Administration, the girl is now fourteen. Her father has been invited to school since the girl is in trouble for sending a boy a note and it is not for the first time. In Enebeli's eyes, the boy is not appealing. He is short and one of his ears is significantly larger than the other. He also spots a terrible haircut. He is saved from Enebeli only because, like everybody else, he is confused about the girl's attention. This particular note reads, “Buki, I love you, I will give you many sons.” Enebeli struggles not to guffaw but wonders where the girl gets all these – definitely not from her  mother or him. Assuring the head teacher that it will not happen again, he promises to chastise her. It happens two more times before the girl learns to pass notes better. Enebeli deems his daughter his brightest ember and will not dim her. Her mother attempts to correct her but much is lost in transmission over the wire. Her influence as a mother has been diluted because of the long absence and distance. She disagrees with Enebeli concerning the training up of the girl. Later, trying to close the distance between her mother and her, she tells him about the boy, stringing out his virtues like Christmas lights. He is shorter so he has to obey her and he is finally learning how to kiss better. The mother is disappointed. She says she did not think she would raise that kind of a girl. This remark dampens the girl till Enebeli is worried. “And there is a little less light to her”. The mother’s absence is surely an obstacle to effective parenting.

Secondly, when Enebeli’s wife goes to the US and stays for a few years, there is a serious strain in communication between her daughter and her. The first month she had gone to the States, the family would speak to each other several times a day. The mother and daughter would have their cordial time, full of tears and I miss yous and affectionate questions like “When are you coming home?”. When she returns for Christmas holidays, the girl barely leaves her side.  However, the parents make their first big mistake when they decide that the mother stays in the US until she completes her studies. The girl then learns how to survive without her mother. For one relationship to thrive, another must not. The conversations between mother and daughter via Skype dwindle. They become merely friendly conversations where they exchange news and update each other on situations. There is a whiff of distance as if the girl is talking to a favourite aunt whom she loves dearly but would not tell about a boy. The distance causes difficulty in communication between the mother and daughter.

Thirdly, the mother’s attempt to prepare the girl for the world causes resentment between them instead. As much as she is still a girl, she is almost a woman who needs a mother’s guidance and counsel. The mother tries to teach her not to laugh too loudly or to chew carelessly that she can hear it all the way in America. She also tells her that she is old enough to be cooking and that Daddy should not make her breakfast. The distance between the two widens until she does not enjoy talking to the mother anymore. It begins to feel like a chore. Since the mother is far, she faces hurdles in giving her daughter the necessary life lessons vital for the growth and development of a teenage girl.

Also, the mother is worried about the house girl whom she thinks will influence her daughter negatively.  Despite having a house girl, father and daughter share household chores. They are too intimidated by the sullen house girl who spends most of the time watching 'Africa Magic' while mopping a small section of tile till it gleams. When not pretending to clean, she talks to the girl in whispers. Enebeli is not concerned since they cannot cause much trouble as long as they are in the house. He muses that talk is just talk when he tells his wife about this. The wife is terrified that the daughter could acquire inappropriate traits from the house girl. She nags until Enebeli sends her packing. The daughter becomes sullen after this. She waits with crossed arms for the Skype calls to end. This strained relationship is caused by the distance between them.

Due to her mother’s absence, the girl misses important life lessons necessary for a teenage girl. Such lessons are better taught by mothers. Enebeli does not understand what the world does to daughters. Enebeli and his daughter survive much in the absence of the mother who is in America studying for a Masters in Business Administration. The girl is only eleven. They survive the disturbance at the market when two warring women cause a commotion that sees them separated for hours. They also survive an adult talk when an uncle makes a careless joke at a wedding. The curious girl has questions so Enebeli labours to answer lest she asks somebody else who may take it as an invitation to demonstrate. The mother would have been better placed to handle this trial. They also survive the crime scene of the girl's first “moon time”. It seeps all the way through the other side of the mattress. They survived the girl discovering it would happen every month. Had the mother been around, she would have taken her through the relevant lessons and prepared her for the changes. Distance hinders effectual parenting.

Furthermore, because of her mother’s absence, the girl fails to learn basic grooming and etiquette. The mother cautions her against chewing carelessly and laughing rather too loudly. She becomes nit-picky, struggling to ease her daughter’s passage. She is concerned about what the girl is wearing. She advises her to sit with her legs crossed at the ankle. She also wonders when the girl last had a relaxer as her hair is scattered. Enebeli panics when the wife suggests that she would call her sister. The sister is a terrifyingly competent woman with three polished boys and the money to take another child. In his fit of panic, Enebeli buys cream to attempt and fix the girl's hair. He massages it into her scalp like lotion and the smell makes both their eyes water. When he washed it out, half of her hair comes out. When the mother’s sister comes, she silently notices the over processed mess and the scab forming on the girl's forehead. When she bring her back her hair is shorn and cut close to the scalp. She turns her head, preening. The mother admits that she has a lovely shaped skull but ruins everything when she adds that she can’t wait for the hair to grow back so that she looks like a proper girl again. This causes another fight between her and Enebeli. They feel like strangers. The distance contributes to this fallout.

Lastly, the girl is forced to take sides when the parents fight. When she comes back from her aunt’s, everyone including the mother agree that her skull has quite the lovely shape. However, the mother ruins it when she says she can’t wait for the hair to grow back so that she looks like a proper girl again. This starts another argument between the parents. The mild fight peppers with time. Distance subtracts warmth, context and history. Husband and wife feel like they are arguing with a stranger. The girl stops talking to her mother after that remark. Naturally, the mother pleads with Enebeli to soften her. He agrees but does not comply. He enjoys when the girl is angry at her mother, and when she is on his side. As much as the girl does not hold grudges, the distance between her and the mother widens an is now akin to something curious. Arimah refers to it as an elephant of mistrust and awkwardness.

In conclusion, the tension between mother and daughter is as a result of the distance between them. A child needs both parents in order to grow properly. A teenage girl needs her mother to guide her otherwise she battles a myriad of challenges. 



Read KCSE ESSAYS ON MEMORIES WE LOST


Read the analyses of the following stories. Use the links below:



2 comments:

Share your feedback with Wekati now

Featured Post

ESSAY: SILENT SONG KCSE ESSAY QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

A SILENT SONG AND OTHER STORIES ESSAY QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ©Wafula Wekati   Share A SILENT SONG ESSAY QUESTION When someone ...